Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

01/10/07

Accurate Birthdates – Do They Matter?

Posted by : Julie in Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog at 07:54 am , 397 words, 96 views  
Categories: Adoptions, Media
I read an interesting article yesterday about immigrants’ birthdays in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Seems there are several people who immigrate to the US each year that have no record or knowledge of their birthdays. They come from cultures or areas where this piece of information is not used or recorded. Or their calendar systems and ways of tracking dates is different than ours.

So, if an immigrant doesn’t know his/her birthday, the government assigns them one – January 1. The article talks about the large number of immigrant children in certain Atlanta-area schools with January 1 birthdays. African countries were mentioned as those where the immigrants often don’t know their birthdays or their calendars are seasonal instead of in months like ours. The Somali interpreter at one school explains that Somalis don’t tend to celebrate birthdays as Americans do.

SPONSOR

This was fascinating to me, because on many international adoption lists there are heated discussions about “true” birthdays for our children. We lament that there might be inaccuracies in actual birthdates. We worry about how they will feel when they learn that the date may be off by a few days, weeks or even months.

(I’m not talking about the need to change a child’s age based on physical evidence/developmental tests that show the child’s age is wrong. I’m talking about our great concern that we just don’t know, for sure, 100% that the day we are told at adoption is our child’s birthday is truly the exact date.)

The interesting thing to me, was the quote by this Somali interpreter at the end of this article. “Their feeling is,” the interpreter explains, “As long as I’m in America, I don’t care.”

So, maybe we overdo the birthday thing? Maybe we worry for nothing. My understanding of birthday celebrations…when I step back and look at it…is a chance to make the person feel special, remembered, loved. A day to mark the passage of time, of maturing (of aging). And maybe a day to count our blessings of being able to be together and as the immigrants would say…be in America.

(Now I’ll get comments from those who aren’t in America, but you have to know that I do feel blessed to be in such a rich, abundant and comfortable country, despite our many flaws!)

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: klkillian [Member] Email
I'll weigh on this one.

I teach a class of 5th graders for Sunday school. Like me, about half of the kids are "summer birthdays" and don't ever get to celebrate their birthday with their class.

I know I always hated this, so for my "summer kids" I surprise them one day during the school and we celebrate their birthday. We get everyone before class adjourns in the end of May.

The kids don't care that it's their not their actual birthday. All they care about is someone remembered them, and made a big deal about it, even if it was only to bring a treat for them.

I don't think the calendar date is as important as a child feeling special.

Just my 2 cents, and worth what you paid for it. :)
PermalinkPermalink 01/10/07 @ 10:36
Comment from: vivianjean [Member] Email
Some of the parents in our local adoption group have said that for their kids who don't know their actual birthdays, it is a painful reminder of all that they don't know about their early lives and history. It seems to be more of an issue in adoptions from countries where accurate record keeping isn't the norm.
PermalinkPermalink 01/10/07 @ 14:35
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
I have that situation with my daughter, and it grieves me that as a result of being abandoned, she doesn't even have THAT fact of her life... something I took for granted until I was parenting a child who didn't know that information. Since I recently celebrated my birthday (a huge milestone, yes, thank you very much...) and my folks were here, my dad repeated the story I have heard for half a century and could repeat for 4+ decades... "It was when the doctor and I were eating ice cream in the hospital cafeteria that they paged him over the intercom to hasten to the Labor and Delivery room..." (My folks were social friends with the doc and his wife, small town America...how weird would THAT be?) Anyway, not only do I know the exact day, but the exact time, and all the events around it. I spent a long time on the phone today with a gal in Canada who started a group for folks who were abandoned... and this very issue was one of many we discussed. I'll blog on it too!

Great post Julie.
PermalinkPermalink 01/10/07 @ 16:08
Comment from: adoptingmama [Member] Email
I'm with klkillian. I never once got to bring cupcakes to school for my July birthday. I would have loved to have another designated day to celebrate with my classmates. (why didn't the teachers think of that??)

Dawn S
PermalinkPermalink 03/26/07 @ 22:57
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • KatjaMichelle Email
  • Guest Users: 194