http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

04/02/07

Consequences, Restitution and Who's Responsible? - Part 2

Posted by : Julie in Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog at 08:22 am , 367 words, 87 views  
Categories: Therapeutic
I’m still thinking about the consequences/restitution thing. Kinda like the merry-go-round the girl in the picture's on...it keeps going 'round & 'round in my brain. One reader recommended that I read Beyond Consequences, Logic and Control ,the book by Bryan Post and Heather Forbes. I’ve got to say that this book is quite the lightning rod, quite the buzz generator. If Bryan & Heather’s marketing folks are reading this blog, my hats are off to you. (I don’t agree with the marketing approach, but it has definitely generated buzz…so that makes it successful from a marketing professional’s standpoint.) I have never seen a book about attachment and trauma that has been the topic of so many listserves, so many blogs, and has produced such strong reactions.

I haven’t read it. In fact, Iblogged about that fact over a year ago. And since then, I’ve had numerous people both recommend and warn me about this book. In fact, just a couple weeks ago a mom I admire a great deal contacted me about the book and about how disturbed she was about a number of things in it…first that the focus seems to be squarely on the parents dealing with their own “stuff” that keeps them from being able to accept the kids’ behaviors. So much so that it appears that it’s mostly the parents “stuff” that is getting in the way of healing these kids. (Oh were that true, my daughter would have had such an easier life and we wouldn’t be in the bloody school battles we’re in!) And second that the book put down the work of other attachment and trauma therapists. This dismayed my friend, because like me, she has found help for her child by piecing together a huge number of interventions, treatments and parenting styles. We both believe that no one person has all the answers for our kids. And that if anything the attachment community should be pulling together to let the world know of these children's challenges. It's not easy for parents of traumatized children to find the often rare resource of experienced attachment therapists.

SPONSOR
Click Here to Visit www.pamelaobr.com

continued...

Photo Credit

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: vivianjean [Member] Email
"no one person has all the answers for our kids."

Amen! Multiple therapists, multiple approaches allow parents to decide what works for their child. We've learned the hard way. We're still learning.

I read BCLC. I tried to implement their approach and it failed miserably. Our children's behaviors increased. I haven't gotten around to that money back guarantee the authors offer! I do think there are useful pearls in this book. Since it can be easy to look at a child with RAD very negatively, they offer parents a new way to view their children. However, I agree with your friend about the ridiculous amount of energy they expend on the "parents issues." Further, the put downs of other professionals is not considered ethical by most credentialed practitioners.

I know fans love this book, but just based on what you've written about LuLu I imagine that this approach as a single treatment plan probably wouldn't be beneficial.

PermalinkPermalink 04/02/07 @ 09:10
Comment from: Angela [Member] Email · http://ukraine.adoptionblogs.com/
I don't count myself as a fan. And I don't think it is the "answer".

But I agree with a lot of it. I agree there is a lot on the parent. And there should be.

Post likes to say, "If Mom isn't happy, then the family isn't happy".

Or another way to look at this. The primary caretaker for the family needs to take care of himself/herself.

And sometimes this may be therapy or a night out once a month or a date night or attending church. Everyone has to pick what is right for them.

I learned the hard way that I must have time away to recharge.

I needed understand why I felt such angry over a little issue. So it took Natasha 2 minutes more (then I expected) to tie her shoe laces. We weren't late for anything. Why was I so stressed out over something so small.

Sometimes it is the parent's issues getting in the way of the child's healing. But I don't see that as a focus of the book.

Honestly if your child doesn't have an anxiety disorder, PTSD.. if your child doesn't feel constantly stressed... if your child isn't fresh from the orphanage... I am not sure there is value for a family.

The book is about dealing with stressed out children. I need to reread it and see if the neuro science is mentioned.

The book's theory is based on actual neuro science. It is based on PTSD studies of war veterans. It is based on brain stress studies.

And the theory comes from one author's childhood. He was a RAD foster child.
PermalinkPermalink 04/02/07 @ 11:24
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Misc

Subscribe to Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 129