http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

03/19/07

Stay Away from the Mentally Ill Kid!

Posted by : Julie in Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog at 05:52 am , 614 words, 111 views  
Categories: A Day In the Life..., You've Got To Be Kidding Me!
Here’s an interesting, but not surprising, article from the Health Behavior News Service:
New research suggests that Americans are more likely to socially reject children with mental illness than they are those with physical illnesses such as asthma.


Well...duh! Mental illnesses are scarier, misunderstood, less likely to be believed as a “real” illness. Even in circles where discriminatory comments about race, religion, ethnic background or even weight or age are unacceptable – “crazy” is still fair game.

Almost 30 percent of the 1,134 participants said they would not like their child to become friends of a child with depression, and almost one in four said the same thing about ADHD. Roughly 20 percent said they did not want a child with either ADHD or depression living next door. But when asked about friendship with children with ”normal troubles” and asthma symptoms, negative responses dropped to 10 percent or less in all categories.

SPONSOR
   123


Part of me wants to understand this – especially since I have a child so far outside the norm behaviorally. It requires a great deal of coaching and adult involvement sometimes to set up “normal” peer-to-peer interactions for LuLu. When I look at it from their side, I’m not sure I would want my child playing with LuLu. The study does go on to say that parents are less concerned that a mentally ill child attend the same school as their child, but they just don't want them to socially interact. For gosh sake folks, your kids are not going to catch my child’s neurological disorders!

The rejection seems to affect me more than LuLu – perhaps because I am better able to understand the subtle ways most people convey it, and she is socially impaired enough not to read the signals. At the times she knows she’s been rejected, my heart nearly breaks. And I don’t know how to tell other parents that it’s an incredible burden on me when they announce that they don’t hang out with us because their children feel uncomfortable around my child. We had some friends tell us about a year ago that LuLu is the reason why they don’t participate in some outings we do with a whole group of families.

It was painful to hear; especially since I wasn’t even asking them why they didn’t participate. “LuLu just makes our S very nervous. So t ask her to spend a whole weekend around LuLu would be too stressful. She is scared to be around her because of the tics and loud outbursts.” Oddly enough, S’s little sister shows great compassion toward LuLu. And this woman’s comments fall in the “if you can’t say something nice, keep it to yourself” category in my opinion. Although I believe she offered it up as a way to be honest (and maybe to ease her conscious a bit)…but it has forever changed my perception, sadly.

The burden on me is to figure out what to do in those situations. Do I try to keep the peace and maintain a “friendship” (although, let’s face it – reject my kid and my side of the relationship IS permanently changed)? Or do I point out to them that this is not only rude and discriminatory, but short-sighted as they are passing up the opportunity to teach their child something valuable about compassion, inclusion and concern for others? The times I’ve pointed it out I am sometimes accused of being bitter or “overreacting”. The times I am silent I stew about it and stay wounded for a very long time.

It's just one more battle to the multi-faceted challenge of raising special kids!

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Julia Fuller [Member] Email · http://special-needs.adoptionblogs.com/
Julie, That's why all of my close friends are foster and adoptive parents with kids just as "weird" as mine. Smile! JUlia
PermalinkPermalink 03/19/07 @ 07:14
Comment from: Kelly [Member] Email · http://fost-adopt.adoptionblogs.com
Julie-

I think of lot of this stems to the criticsm I have been getting from social services. I "made" my child this way. Despite the numerous amounts of documentation that shows his issues stemmed long before he ever met or heard of me, somehow it is MY fault that he is mentally ill.

If this is what suppossedly educated professionals think, what do you think the "average" person sees our family as.

As you know, I have heard this same criticism from my family, and they know about his mental illness as well.

Physical ailments are much easier to accept because they are more visible. Mental illness must be the result of bad parenting.
PermalinkPermalink 03/19/07 @ 08:00
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
Julie, just lose the losers and hang out with folks who want to know more, who want to embrace difference, who understand what really matters. How incredibly myopic and rude to have someone tell you they avoid outings because of LuLu. THEY are the ones with issues! And in my opinion, they are double losers, for they lose an opportunity to spend time with one of the most awesome people I know.... YOU.
PermalinkPermalink 03/19/07 @ 09:23
Comment from: Faith Allen [Member] Email · http://hoping.adoptionblogs.com/
That's interesting. My kid has both asthma and ADHD, and I cannot fathom why either would matter to my next door neighbor. I can see where a teacher might have a preference because she is having to be in charge of the child all day, but a next door neighbor?? Also, I had never thought of my son's ADHD as being a "mental illness."

It's interesting to hear about other people's perceptions because mine are generally pretty different. I don't remotely care what issue another child has as long as my child is not being harmed by it. My kid has a friend w/Turrett's, and that doesn't bother me. I did get upset when a special needs child in my son's class bit my son, leaving an imprint of all of his teeth, but that was because my son was harmed, not because the child has a special need. It would be angry about ANY child biting my kid. This just happened to be a kid w/special needs.

I think you nailed it when you said "the opportunity to teach their child something valuable about compassion, inclusion and concern for others." I will not let my child reject others on any basis other than that another child is mean to him. He does not have to spend time around a child who tries to harm him. We have had talks about how it is okay to not like someone because he is a jerk, but don't dislike someone for superficial reasons. My kid has a really big heart and gets along w/pretty much everyone. It's a shame that more people don't see the value in this.

Take care,

- Faith
PermalinkPermalink 03/19/07 @ 15:19
Comment from: sdiedre [Member] Email
My nephew was born with a rare condition that leaves him wheelchair-bound and unable to talk. Despite that, he is a gorgeous boy with a smile that lights up the room.

When we go to Disneyland it is both a delight (for his sake) and with concern (for the other children) when ALL of the characters rush over to spend time with him....DLand actually asked my brother and SIL if they could use his photo for publicity (he really IS cute).

It was sad for me to realize how easy it was for people to be so attentive to him because he was physically attractive AND because his condition is socially acceptable....our society can be hideously shallow. Downs kids are some of the most affectionate and loving kids....I don't see the DL characters rushing to them!

Kids with emotional or mental disorders are treated as though their condition is transmittable. What a message to send an already hurt child!
PermalinkPermalink 05/13/07 @ 05:05
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Misc

Subscribe to Parenting Children with Special Needs Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 182